- August 16, 2025
Midland ISD Votes to Reinstate “Midland Lee High School” Name Amid Community Divide
Midland, Texas — In a closely divided 4–3 vote on August 12, the Midland Independent School District (MISD) Board of Trustees approved reverting the name of Legacy High School and its freshman campus to Midland Lee High School, partially restoring the institution’s former dedication to Confederate General Robert E. Lee.
Key Details
-
Historical Context
Originally named Robert E. Lee High School when it opened in 1961 amid segregationist policies, the school was renamed Legacy High School in 2020 following a nationwide reckoning sparked by George Floyd’s death. -
The Vote
The board’s narrow 4–3 decision followed a deeply contentious public hearing, with about 45 individuals delivering emotional testimonies. Supporters referenced tradition and community identity, while opponents underscored the racial undertones and ongoing hurt associated with the Lee name. -
Public Reaction
Proponents, including long-time alumni, emphasized legacy—especially athletic and community pride. For example, Tim Lirley commented: “Everybody wants to be a Lee Rebel… Nobody wants to be a Robert E. Lee”.In contrast, critics like Heather Bredimus spoke to the historical harm: named during segregation, the Lee name bears painful implications. Others called the move a misallocation of resources — the rebranding could cost around $62,000.
-
Policy Contradiction
The decision contradicts a newly adopted MISD naming policy, which explicitly prohibits naming facilities after individuals who waged war against the United States—raising legal and ethical questions regarding consistency and procedural integrity.
Implications & Considerations
| Area | Implication |
|---|---|
| Community Unity | The board’s decision risks deepening communal divisions, as many supporters feel perpetuated injustice, while proponents see it as reclaiming cherished identity. |
| Financial Impact | Changing signs, uniforms, and branding could cost the district tens of thousands — funds some argue should prioritize student learning and equity. |
| Education & Inclusion | Restoring a Confederate-associated name may undermine efforts toward inclusivity, especially for students and families who felt alienated by the original designation. |
| Policy Precedent | Overturning a policy-based restriction sets a complex precedent for school naming governance and transparency. |
-
Engage in Healing Dialogue — School leadership should create structured opportunities for genuine community conversations, addressing both heritage and the pain of history.
-
Focus on Educational Priorities — Redirect efforts and resources toward enhancing student outcomes, equity, and school climate.
-
Ensure Governance Integrity — Uphold transparent, fair policymaking in alignment with board resolutions and district standards.